Couch Box Sports logo Couch Box SportsSports talk from the couch
NFL

NFL Trade Value Chart and How Teams Price Draft Picks

I have been talking myself out of the same bad trade in Madden since about 2009. Somebody offers two second rounders for my pick near the top of the first, the trade meter says the deal is fair, I take it, and three seasons later I have...

A draft room table with a printed draft pick value chart, a team notepad and a phone off the hook

I have been talking myself out of the same bad trade in Madden since about 2009. Somebody offers two second rounders for my pick near the top of the first, the trade meter says the deal is fair, I take it, and three seasons later I have four average starters and no quarterback. The game taught me a pricing system that real front offices stopped using around the time I started playing.

The reason that happens is that most trade logic, in games and in television graphics, still runs on a chart drawn up in the early 1990s. The league itself has largely moved on, and the gap between the old chart and the way picks are actually priced today explains a long list of draft day trades that looked like robbery and were not.

The chart everyone still quotes

The famous one is the Jimmy Johnson chart, put together by the Dallas staff in the early 1990s. It gives every one of the 224 or so draft slots a point value, and the shape of it is brutally steep. The first overall pick is 3,000 points. The 16th pick is 1,000. By the end of the first round you are at about 590. The first pick of the second round is roughly 580, the last pick of the second is near 270, and by the seventh round the numbers fall into single digits.

Read those numbers again, because the implication is strange. On that chart, the top pick is worth more than the entire second and third rounds of a team's draft combined. It was never built from research into how players actually performed. Dallas reverse engineered it from the trades teams were already making, so it describes a market rather than a value, and the market it described is now more than thirty years old.

It survives because it is simple and because it is on screen every April. It also survives in games. When you see a trade evaluated instantly as fair, you are usually looking at a descendant of that chart, which is why trading down almost always feels like free money in a video game and much less so in a real draft room.

What the 2011 agreement did to the math

Here is the change that makes the old chart misleading rather than merely dated.

Before 2011, a top pick was expensive. Sam Bradford went first overall in 2010 and signed for six years and around 78 million dollars, with roughly 50 million guaranteed, before playing a professional snap. A team drafting first was committing franchise quarterback money to an unproven player, so the pick carried genuine downside risk.

The rookie wage scale changed that completely. Four year slotted deals, with a fifth year option on first rounders, mean the first overall pick now costs a fraction of market rate. That turns a high pick into something closer to a discounted contract than a gamble, and it raises the value of every early pick relative to late ones in one direction while cutting the risk premium in the other.

The work that followed, most prominently the research by Cade Massey and Richard Thaler, found that teams had historically paid too much to move up. Measured by surplus value, which is production minus what the contract costs, the most valuable picks in the draft sat in the second round and the back half of the first, not at the very top. Their conclusion was that the steep chart described overconfidence, not worth.

So analytically minded teams built flatter charts. The Rich Hill chart and the Fitzgerald and Spielberger surplus chart are the two most quoted publicly. Both narrow the gap between the top of the draft and the middle rounds dramatically, and both make a package of two second rounders look better than the Johnson chart ever would.

The same picks priced three ways

Values below are rescaled so the first overall pick equals 100 on each chart, which is the only way to compare them honestly. The flat column is representative of the publicly available surplus style charts rather than any single one.

PickJohnson chartFlatter surplus style chartWhat the gap means
1st overall100100Same starting point
5th5884Top five picks closer in value
10th4472Moving up inside the top ten costs less
20th2856Late first rounders badly underpriced by the old chart
33rd, first of round two1946The single biggest disagreement
64th930Two seconds now rival a mid first
100th418Day three picks are not rounding errors

Look at the 33rd pick row and a lot of recent draft weekends make more sense. A team holding the top of the second round is holding something close to half the value of the first overall pick on a modern chart and about a fifth of it on the chart your broadcast graphic is using. The team that trades down and takes the criticism is often the one reading the newer number.

Where I think the analytics crowd overreaches

The flat chart people have the better argument and they take it too far. The surplus value framing treats every position as interchangeable production, and the league plainly does not work that way.

Quarterback breaks the model. A team that needs one and does not have one is not optimising surplus value across 53 roster spots, it is trying to solve the only problem that reliably decides seasons. Kansas City moving up to 10 in 2017 for Patrick Mahomes, giving up pick 27, pick 91 and a future first, was a clear overpay on the flat chart and one of the best trades of the decade. Washington going up to 2 in 2012 for Robert Griffin III, giving up pick 6, a second rounder and two future firsts, was a worse overpay on the same chart and it did not work. Same framework, opposite outcomes, because the variable that mattered was whether the player was any good.

The other thing the charts flatten is the future pick discount. Most front offices value a pick a year away at roughly one round lower than the equivalent pick this year, because of uncertainty about where the team will finish and because draft capital now helps a coaching staff that may not be employed next season. No chart I have seen prices that properly, and it is the single biggest difference between a video game trade and a real one. Games will happily hand you next year's first at full face value.

How to judge the next trade you see

Three questions get you most of the way, and none of them need a spreadsheet.

First, which team solved a position it cannot fill any other way? A quarterback or a left tackle is not replaceable by accumulating picks, and the team taking the swing deserves less criticism than the chart suggests. Second, how many of the picks are future picks? Discount each one by about a round and the deal often tilts back. Third, what does the acquiring team's cap situation look like, because draft capital and cap space are partly interchangeable, and a team carrying a lot of dead money needs cheap rookie contracts more than a healthy one does.

One honest caveat. Nobody outside the buildings knows which chart any particular team uses, and several clubs are known to run their own proprietary version weighted by their own hit rates by round. Everything public is a reasonable approximation built from trades, which means it inherits whatever errors the market is making. Treat the numbers as a way to ask better questions rather than a verdict, the same way the formula behind compensatory picks tells you roughly what to expect without telling you exactly. More of this sort of thing sits in our NFL coverage.

FAQ

Is the Jimmy Johnson chart still used?

As a reference point and in broadcasts, constantly. As the actual basis for a front office decision, much less than it was. Most clubs run some blend of a surplus value model and their own scouting confidence, which is why public reaction to a trade so often disagrees with both teams involved.

Why do video game trades feel so easy?

Because the underlying logic is steep and static. It prices the top of the draft high, prices future picks at face value, and does not model the rookie wage scale or the fifth year option. Trading down repeatedly works beautifully in a game and would get a general manager fired.

Which draft picks give the best return?

By surplus value, the research points at the back of the first round through the second round, where the contract cost drops faster than the hit rate does. That is an average across many drafts, not a guarantee for any single pick.

How much is a future first rounder worth?

A common working rule is one round of discount per year of delay, so next year's first trades at roughly the value of this year's early second. Teams that expect to be bad next year value their own future picks higher, which is part of why rebuilding clubs are reluctant sellers of them.

TO
Teddy Okonjo

Teddy plays every new sports title on release week and compares the virtual game with the real one.

More posts by Teddy

More in NFL

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto