College Sports NIL Deals and How the Money Actually Flows
A guy in my fantasy league asked me last fall whether Texas pays Arch Manning directly or whether a booster writes the check. The answer in 2024 was the booster.

A guy in my fantasy league asked me last fall whether Texas pays Arch Manning directly or whether a booster writes the check. The answer in 2024 was the booster. The answer in 2026 is both, through two separate systems with different rules, different approval processes, and different tax treatment. Almost nobody watching a Saturday game can explain the difference, which is how you end up with a comment section convinced that every roster move is a bidding war when roughly half of it still is not.
I play every college football title on release week and I have spent more hours than is reasonable inside recruiting menus, so I came at this from the game side first. The sliders in a dynasty mode forced me to learn what the real categories are, because the game splits the money into buckets and I could not tell which bucket matched which real-world thing. Here is the version I wish somebody had written for me.
The Three Buckets The Money Comes From
Start with the only one that existed before July 2021. Real endorsement deals are a player signing with a business to appear in advertising, sign autographs, or post about a product. A quarterback doing a regional truck dealership spot is this. So is a gymnast with two million followers taking a skincare brand deal, which is the category where some of the highest individual earners in college sports are not football or basketball players at all. These deals are negotiated at market rates, they are taxable income, and the school is not a party to them.
Second, collectives. These are organizations set up by boosters and fans of a specific school to pool money and pay athletes, nominally for appearances and charity work and social posts, functionally as recruiting and retention money. From 2021 to 2025 this was where the serious cash lived. A top-tier football program's collective was reportedly moving somewhere in the range of 10 to 20 million dollars a year, and almost none of it was audited by anyone the public could see.
Third, and new since the 2025-26 academic year, direct payment from the school. The House settlement approved in June 2025 ended the rule that schools could not share revenue with athletes. Each participating school can now distribute up to a cap, set around 20.5 million dollars in the first year and scheduled to rise annually, across all of its athletes. That is one pot for every sport, which means the allocation decision inside an athletic department is now one of the most consequential and least transparent choices in college sports.
What The Settlement Actually Changed
Three things, and only one of them is the money.
The cap is the headline. Most power conference football programs are reportedly sending something like 70 to 75 percent of their allowance to football, with men's basketball next, and the rest split thin. A 20.5 million dollar pot sounds enormous until you divide the football share across 105 players and notice that the median figure is not life-changing while the top of the roster takes a large chunk.
The second change is the clearinghouse. Third-party NIL deals above 600 dollars now have to be submitted for review, run through a system built with Deloitte and overseen by the new College Sports Commission, which checks whether the payment reflects a plausible market value for actual services. The intent is to stop a collective from calling a recruiting payment an endorsement. Whether it survives the litigation aimed at it is a different question, and I would not bet heavily either way.
The third change is roster limits replacing scholarship limits. Football went to a hard 105, and every player on the roster can be on a full scholarship. That sounds generous. In practice it cut walk-on spots at a lot of programs, and the people most affected were specialists and depth players who were never getting NIL money in the first place.
Who Pays What, And Who Signs Off
| Source | Typical size | Who approves it | Counts against the cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| National brand endorsement | Low thousands to seven figures | Clearinghouse review above 600 dollars | No |
| Local business deal | 500 to 25,000 dollars | Clearinghouse review above 600 dollars | No |
| Collective payment | Varies wildly by school | Clearinghouse, with the most scrutiny | No, but pressure is on this bucket |
| Direct school revenue share | Thousands to low millions per athlete | Athletic department allocation | Yes |
| Game and media licensing | 600 to roughly 1,500 dollars per player | Group licensing agreement | No |
| Scholarship and cost of attendance | Tuition plus stipend | Compliance office | No |
That bottom licensing row is the one closest to my own beat. When the college football game came back in 2024, athletes who opted in received 600 dollars and a copy of the game, and over 11,000 of them signed up. The follow-up raised the per-player figure, reported around 1,500 dollars, and added more athletes. For a backup offensive lineman at a mid-tier program, that licensing check may genuinely be the largest NIL payment he receives all year, which tells you how uneven the distribution is.
The Loudest Complaint Is The Wrong One
The common take is that NIL destroyed roster continuity, and that paying players is why your team loses four starters every January. I think that gets the causation backwards, and I have changed my mind on it since 2023.
The thing that moves players is the transfer rule, not the money. Before 2018 a transfer generally sat out a year, and that penalty held rosters together far more effectively than poverty ever did. Once the one-time transfer exception and then the open portal removed the sitting-out cost, movement was always going to spike. Money raises the stakes of each individual decision, but a player who can leave freely and start immediately somewhere else will leave for playing time alone. Scroll through portal entries and you find a long tail of backups with no NIL market at all, chasing snaps. The roster churn story is told in more detail in the piece on how the portal reshaped recruiting.
The second half of the complaint, that NIL created competitive imbalance, deserves a harder look too. Alabama and Ohio State dominated recruiting when the official compensation was zero. The programs with money have always had money. What changed is that the payments are now visible, and visible payments feel more offensive than invisible ones even when the underlying advantage is identical.
Where I think the criticism lands is the information gap. A 17 year old is negotiating a multi-year financial arrangement with no agent in many cases, no standardized contract, no guarantee the collective still exists in 18 months, and tax obligations he has never dealt with. That is a real problem and almost nobody is fixing it.
How The Game Handles It
Dynasty mode models this with a simplified version: a budget, a set of player motivations, and a cap you cannot exceed. The useful part is the allocation pressure, because you feel immediately that paying your starting quarterback market value means somebody in your two-deep gets nothing and transfers in December. That trade-off is the actual job of a modern athletic department, and the game communicates it better than most television segments do. Where it falls short is the chaos: real collectives miss payments, real deals fall apart, and no video game wants to simulate a booster losing interest in March. More on that gap in the comparison of dynasty recruiting against the real thing, and the rest of the explainers sit in the college section.
FAQ
Are college athletes employees now?
No, not under the settlement. They receive revenue share payments without employee status, which is why there is no collective bargaining and no union contract. Several active lawsuits are pushing on exactly that point.
Do all schools pay the full cap?
No. The figure is a ceiling, not a requirement, and schools outside the power conferences mostly cannot approach it. A few opted out of the settlement framework entirely.
Can high school recruits sign NIL deals?
It depends on the state and the high school association, and the rules differ enough that two recruits in neighboring states can face opposite answers. School-linked payments generally cannot begin before enrollment.
Does NIL money count as taxable income?
Yes, and most of it arrives as independent contractor income with nothing withheld. Players owe quarterly estimated taxes, which is the part that catches first-year earners out most often.
More in College
College
College Football Playoff Seeding and How the Byes Work
In December 2024 the first 12-team College Football Playoff bracket came out and a lot of people stared at it like it had been...
College
Heisman Trophy Voting and How the Winner Is Chosen
Every December the same argument breaks out in group chats and on talk radio: how did that guy win the Heisman when my guy had...
College
College Football Redshirt Rules and the Four Game Limit
Every November the same question pops up on broadcasts and message boards: why is that freshman suddenly sitting after playing...